Anywho, the list is far shorter than I might have imagined. But of course the sport that apparently has the most out medalist is...figure skating. Four to be specific:
What makes a sport gay anyway? Public perception? Sequins? Jazz Hands? Tights? I asked around my work area what my coworkers thought and I got some unusual responses. Ballet (to which the guy next to him remarked Ballet wasn't a sport...but that's another argument!), Gymnastics, Wrestling, Diving, Cycling, Cheerleading (another tort about the validity of that as a sport!), and also Figure Skating.
Hmmm...in fairness, in all these sports the guys do sometimes wear tights or at least tighter clothing. It must be tight clothes that make a sport gay...maybe not? And nobody said soccer....hmmmm.